News archive, 2008

Vulture review calls the Notorious biopic script shallow

New York magazine's Vulture blog read the 113-page Notorious B.I.G. biopic script and said it plays like a highlight reel, not a deep portrait.

Curated by EllePublished Restored and fact-checked Based on reporting by Vulture, New York Magazine

From the NotoriousOnline news archive. First published on February 27, 2008. It describes events as they stood then. This version is rewritten in our own words from the original report and credits it.

The Vulture blog at New York magazine read the screenplay for Notorious, the Notorious B.I.G. biopic, and was not encouraged. Vulture had hoped the film would be the smart, probing portrait that his legacy deserves, despite repeated delays, changes of director and the producers' decision to find their lead through an internet talent search.

The 113-page script, written by journalist Cheo Hodari Coker, tries to fit an entire life, short as it was, into a two-hour film. Vulture noted that recent music biographies have worked better when they covered a limited stretch of their subjects' lives. 8 Mile, for example, concentrated on Eminem's early, pre-fame career, which gave it a natural story arc and told viewers something new. On paper, Notorious reads like a loose collection of highlights, essentially a screenplay version of Biggie's Wikipedia entry.

The story opens with his murder and funeral and then goes back to his Brooklyn childhood. It shows him at home, in the classroom and dealing crack on the corner, with rap posters in his bedroom and a rhyme book that he fills during a nine-month prison sentence. It never explains how an enthusiastic fan became one of hip-hop's most respected emcees. By page 30 he has signed to Puffy's label, and the rest moves quickly to the end of his biography. Conflicts such as his mother's breast cancer, the tension with the mothers of his children and the love triangles involving Faith Evans, Lil' Kim and Tupac are each settled within a scene or two.

Voletta Wallace and Biggie's managers Wayne Barrow and Mark Pitts, all credited as producers, reportedly gave input on the script. That shows in how many of his key moments are told after the fact, in conversations with them. The audience learns of his marriage to Evans only when he tells Barrow and Pitts about a month afterward, although it does see him ask the two of them to manage him. He denies any part in either shooting of Tupac only in phone calls with his mother.

The script does not name a killer in his death, which Vulture considered understandable. The shooter's face is never shown. A scene shows him in a garage cleaning and oiling his weapon. He has police scanners on his workbench and in his car, and LAPD credentials on his dashboard let him drive through a police blockade on the way to the murder. The script offers no speculation about who he is or who he might have been working for.

Vulture did not call the script a complete failure. The early pages about Biggie's adolescence were compelling enough, and the reviewers wished they had been the focus. Two thirds of the story take place after he is already famous and dwell on his success rather than his early ambition or talent, which would have been more appealing. Vulture doubted that anyone would find much inspiration in his fame or record sales, which were hard to repeat even in the nineties and more so in the current music business. In its view, the filmmakers would do better to concentrate on what made him one of rap's greats, or at least to include a scene or two of him sharpening his craft.

Vulture wanted a penetrating look at the man who made Ready to Die. Instead it found a film with roughly the depth of a single-disc greatest hits collection, and it advised readers to lower their expectations.