From the NotoriousOnline news archive. First published on May 27, 2006. It describes events as they stood then. This version is rewritten in our own words from the original report and credits it.
The federal judge who declared a mistrial in the Notorious B.I.G. wrongful death lawsuit, and who later ordered Los Angeles to pay $1.1 million to the rapper's family, said in May 2006 that she had been deceived about evidence in the case, according to the Los Angeles Times.
U.S. District Judge Florence-Marie Cooper ordered Perry R. Sanders Jr., one of the family's lawyers, to explain a document that appeared to undercut a central claim he made at the 2005 trial. The rapper was killed in an unsolved drive-by shooting in 1997 outside the Petersen Automotive Museum in Los Angeles. At the trial, Sanders had said he held no information about an alleged police conspiracy behind the murder.
Cooper declared the mistrial in the summer of 2005 after finding that a Los Angeles police detective had hidden statements linking the killing to LAPD Officers David A. Mack and Rafael Perez. In January she ordered the city to pay the family's attorney fees and costs as a sanction for withholding evidence. The Times reported that Cooper now said the family had deceived her, and the city said Sanders had information on the alleged conspiracy long before the trial.
As proof, the city gave Cooper a four-page report that a private investigator working for the family wrote in November 2002. According to Vincent Marella, a lawyer for the city, the report details an interview with a prison informant that the family said it had never seen. "This shows beyond any question that everything they said they never had, they had," Marella told the Times.
Sanders denied the claims. He told the paper that his firm was "not hiding anything from anybody" and that he had given the city the document before the trial. He said the firm opened its entire file to police in an effort to solve a murder, not to build a lawsuit.