News archive, 2007

Judge dismisses defamation suit over Notorious B.I.G. killing coverage

A Superior Court judge dismissed Tyruss Himes' defamation suit against KTTV and XXL over reports linking him to the Notorious B.I.G. killing.

Curated by EllePublished Restored and fact-checked Based on reporting by the Associated Press

From the NotoriousOnline news archive. First published on January 20, 2007. It describes events as they stood then. This version is rewritten in our own words from the original report and credits it.

A judge dismissed a defamation lawsuit brought by a man who said that Fox Television and a hip-hop magazine falsely linked him to the unsolved murder of the rapper Notorious B.I.G.

On Thursday, January 18, 2007, a Superior Court judge threw out the suit by Tyruss Himes against the Fox-owned Los Angeles station KTTV and XXL magazine. The judge granted the defendants' motions to dismiss on the grounds that the stories were constitutionally protected free speech. According to Himes' attorney, Arthur G. Lesmez, the judge also found that Himes had not shown that the outlets acted with malice and reckless disregard for the truth, which is the standard of proof in defamation cases.

Lesmez said on Friday, January 19, that his client was disappointed and was weighing his options, including an appeal or refiling the case. "We're understandably disappointed in the decision," he said.

Notorious B.I.G., whose real name was Christopher Wallace, was shot to death in a car on March 9, 1997. There have been recurring rumors that the shooting was retaliation for the unsolved 1996 killing of Tupac Shakur in Las Vegas. The two rappers were feuding at the time. Himes was a friend of Shakur and performed on his album Loyal to the Game.

Himes filed the suit in July 2006. He claimed that he lost a record deal because KTTV aired a news report that linked him to Wallace's killing and because XXL published a 2005 article indicating that he helped assemble the team that murdered Wallace.